How to Choose the Right AC System for Your Home


Homeowners often feel overwhelmed when shopping for a new AC, especially when they’re scrambling to beat the summer heat. There are many important considerations for air conditioning installation: comfort preferences, home size and layout, efficiency targets, and more. Let’s explore what you should know to avoid high energy bills and uneven cooling.

Factors to Consider When Choosing an AC System

Professional AC installation is important because there are so many factors to consider. Overlooking one or more can result in higher costs now and in the years ahead.

Key areas you’ll need to account for include:
  • Home size and layout
  • Existing ductwork
  • Comfort and cooling challenges
  • Energy efficiency and budget

Home Size and Layout

Smaller homes are easier to cool, while larger houses present unique challenges. The general guideline is to aim for 20 to 30 BTUs of cooling output per square foot. You must also account for your home’s ceiling heights and floor plan. Homes with open floor plans, multiple levels, or difficult-to-cool rooms, such as sunrooms and server rooms, all require additional cooling output.

Existing Ductwork

While you can use your existing ductwork, there are some important considerations. Rigid metal ductwork can last 25 years or more, and that’s the point at which you want to consider replacing it. Even with younger ductwork, you may need maintenance and repairs, including duct sealing. It may also be worthwhile considering upgrades, including mechanical ventilation and duct dampers.

Comfort and Cooling Challenges

It’s also important to account for your home’s unique building envelope. As a house ages, its envelope can become looser, presenting several cooling challenges.

Professional AC sizing and selection can help you account for:
  • Uneven temperatures
  • Inconsistent airflow
  • Warmer upstairs levels
  • More humid lower levels

Energy Efficiency and Budget

Modern AC systems can greatly improve efficiency, thereby reducing your operating costs and household carbon footprint. Maximizing your investment requires balancing the upfront costs with the long-term energy savings. An expert installer can help you choose the SEER2 rating that strikes that balance. While the minimum is between 13.4 and 14.3, depending on your location, many find their sweet spot between 15.2 and 17.0. Those higher ratings may also make you eligible to claim rebates, tax credits, and other incentives.

Comparing Popular Residential Cooling Systems

There are multiple configurations available for your air conditioner replacement. Those include central and ductless air conditioning, as well as heat pump systems.

Central AC Systems

Central air conditioner on a concrete pad outside of a home

Over two-thirds of U.S. homes have central cooling. Central AC is simply the most effective and efficient way to provide consistent cooling throughout an entire home, especially large ones. It’s an ideal option for houses that already have ducts. There are also add-ons available to make central AC even more efficient, including smart thermostats and zone control systems.

Ductless Mini-Split Systems

Ductless mini-split air handler mounted on a gray wall

Ductless mini-splits don’t need ducts because they have individual indoor air handlers. That integrated zone control makes these systems inherently more efficient than basic central arrangements. Mini-splits are ideal for older houses without ducts and for adding central AC zoning to bedrooms. They’re also a popular choice for home additions, finished basements, garages, and home offices.

Heat Pumps

Heat pump mounted on the outside of a brick house
Side view of outdoor energy unit hanging on brick wall of house on a sunny day. Air to air heat pump for cooling or heating the home. Outdoor unit powered by renewable energy. Air conditioner and air heat pump.

A heat pump is similar to an AC, but it can reverse its refrigeration cycle to provide heating as well. That heating is often much cheaper than from traditional options like furnaces and boilers. Consider a heat pump if you want to upgrade your HVAC system to an all-in-one solution that provides year-round comfort. Heat pumps are available in both ducted and ductless configurations.

Why Proper Sizing and Installation Matter

There is no one-size-fits-all solution for cooling output. AC experts recommend custom load calculations to achieve accurate sizing for a particular home.

Oversized and undersized systems both lead to serious problems:
  • Uneven cooling
  • Poor humidity control
  • Irregular system cycling
  • Higher long-term equipment costs

Through a professional air conditioner replacement, you can maximize comfort, reliability, efficiency, and system lifespan. Experts also recommend replacing your AC before summer. It’s generally less expensive and more convenient, and early replacement will help you avoid emergency breakdowns during the summer.

Let Us Help You Choose the Best AC for Your Home

Trust McCrea Heating & Air for your custom air conditioning installation. We serve homeowners from our locations in Bridgeville, DE; Temple Hills, MD; Greencastle, PA; and Warrenton, VA. Let us help you beat the heat before peak summer demand and your current system breaks down.

Call today to schedule a consultation to help you choose the perfect system for your home and budget.

Frequently Asked Questions

How often should I replace my home’s AC system?

You’ll typically want to replace a central AC or ductless mini-split system every 15 to 20 years. We recommend seasonal AC tune-ups to improve efficiency, maximize equipment lifespans, and maintain your full warranty. Seasonal maintenance is also an opportunity to perform preventive repairs and stay current on how your AC system is aging. That will allow you to plan for a new air conditioning installation naturally, rather than doing everything at the last minute.

Will a new AC system improve indoor air quality?

Yes, a new high-efficiency air conditioning installation can significantly improve your air quality. Many modern systems allow for MERV 13 HVAC filters, which remove at least 90% of particles larger than 3.0 microns. High-efficiency ACs provide much better humidity control and can more easily keep relative humidity at 50% or below. Other factors include better air circulation, smart thermostat control, and cleaner internal operation overall.

What time of year is best for installing a new AC system?

At McCrea Heating & Air, we’re able to perform air conditioner replacement at any time of the year. That said, spring and fall are the preferred seasons for installation. Demand for our services is lowest during these periods, and you won’t need home cooling yet.
img McCrea High Efficiency rebate up to $1200 on new Trane Installations Request Information Expires 05/31/26 On qualifying Trane HVAC Systems. Must mention coupon at time of service scheduling. Can’t be combined with other offers. Additional restrictions may apply. Contact McCrea for complete details.
img Free McCrea Membership with purchase of an air scrubber Request Information Expires 05/31/26 Must mention coupon at time of service scheduling. Can’t be combined with other offers. Additional restrictions may apply. Contact McCrea for complete details.
img $50 dollars off any HVAC repair Request Information Expires 05/31/26 Must mention coupon at time of service scheduling. Can’t be combined with other offers. Additional restrictions may apply. Contact McCrea for complete details.
Why mccrea

Commitment to Community

On-time Service

85 Years in Business

Competitive Pricing

Quality Service

Satisfaction Guaranteed